mapat wrote:Guys here have gotten so many incredible results with all kinds of pickups, but one clip that sticks out is Kevin's YRGM clip with the Mighty Mite 1300. You guys have tried out so many kinds of pickups, vintage to modern production. In your opinion, what modern pickup sounds the closest to that old Mighty Mite. Is the EVH Frankenstein it?
That's a really difficult question to answer.
The YRGM clip was with my Shark and there's something magical about that build and I dont think its as simple as the pickup. The 1300 smokes in the Shark and Eric's Reggie #1(but they don't sound the same), so there is definitely something about that pup that no other has been able to replicate (I'm working with MJ to try). I have another one that I'm going to put in my Model A with the short scale mahogany neck and see how close it gets to the Shark tone. that will be quite telling about the performance of the 1300.
Where it gets complicate to answer is I had a DSD in my 1st Model A concept build and thought it was great until I started comparing to my other guitars, as well as Eric's LP Custom. It quickly became average. The reality is these plexi builds are hyper sensitive to every nuance in the signal chain. much more so than a cascaded amp, and not even a player in a modeling amp. a year ago it was suggested to me by a buddy to get a GDEC to practice with. every guitar sounded identical and nothing really happened when i rolled the volume off. I never used it and dumped it. point being, as you start putting more things between the guitar and the first valve, it dilutes the amp's sensitivity to the fragile details of the signal. I do find that the Franky pup gets closer to the Shark when I use the EP pedal. It adds the right amount of sizzle and compression.
back to the model A concept - i decided to try to improve the tone and performance by swapping out the DSD for the franky pup and for that guitar, and my amp, it was night and day better. I think Eric will concur.
i hear a lot of good things about the CC, I have one in my B&W Franky and it's also just okay compared to the Franky and 1300 for my rig. I really never play that guitar because of it. That pup will have to get swapped out at some point.
bottom line, the answer is not that simple, but the Franky pup seems to be the most successful for my rig to get close to the holy grail tone. the 1300 is something special and I'm still looking to find a perfect replica for it.
