Correct staking tools (anvil, swager) for split top turrets?
Posted: Tue Jan 25, 2011 8:16 pm
Dear forum members,
(i know i'm splitting hairs, but i'm sure many would be interested in the question, what the PROPER tools (that have been specially built and intended for this use) for split top turrets are and where to get them)
I'm about to order a few tools and i'm still not sure about the staking tools for the split top turrets. I got modern RS split tops and the ones made by Harwin (which George sold in his shop) - they both are identical in dimensions - also to the old 60's ones. The material is a bit thicker on the old and modern RS turrets though (which also means the holes are smaller on the RS).
Apart from the DIY approach, i found these tools from keystone: http://www.keyelco.com/pdfs/M55p125.pdf" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
I simply want the best tools for the project - ones that give nice and consistent results - i'm aware of the fact that you can get the DIY tools from Hoffmann amps or build them yourself, but i suspect that it is possible to make nicer "flares" with those proper tools - they lead the edges of the turret more evenly, as they have a specially designed tip, unlike a simple bolt that has been "sharpened".
But the problem with these tools is this: the shank diameter of the split top turrets is about 2.55mm-2.60mm (0.1 in - 0.102 in), but both of the swagers that would be best suited for this purpose are meant for .062 (1.57mm) to .098 (2.49mm) and for .110 (2.80mm) to .125 (3.20mm)) - the diameter of the RS turrets falls right in the middle. On the other hand, we're talking about a diameter that is just 0.06-0.11mm bigger than the range of the small swager and 0.20mm smaller than the range of the bigger swager. Would this be a problem with either swager - and which one to get for the split top turrets?
I couldn't find anything from RS for this purpose. Harwin offers some tools, but no idea how they look and they are extremely expensive + have to be ordered from manufacturer.
I would appreciate any input on this - has anybody used the Keystone staking tools for the metro split top turrets? How did it work out? I know these can be bought at Mouser and i saw them also on turretboards.com - only question is if they are a perfect fit for this type of turret?
Thank you very much in advance!
Best regards,
VintageCharlie
(i know i'm splitting hairs, but i'm sure many would be interested in the question, what the PROPER tools (that have been specially built and intended for this use) for split top turrets are and where to get them)
I'm about to order a few tools and i'm still not sure about the staking tools for the split top turrets. I got modern RS split tops and the ones made by Harwin (which George sold in his shop) - they both are identical in dimensions - also to the old 60's ones. The material is a bit thicker on the old and modern RS turrets though (which also means the holes are smaller on the RS).
Apart from the DIY approach, i found these tools from keystone: http://www.keyelco.com/pdfs/M55p125.pdf" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
I simply want the best tools for the project - ones that give nice and consistent results - i'm aware of the fact that you can get the DIY tools from Hoffmann amps or build them yourself, but i suspect that it is possible to make nicer "flares" with those proper tools - they lead the edges of the turret more evenly, as they have a specially designed tip, unlike a simple bolt that has been "sharpened".
But the problem with these tools is this: the shank diameter of the split top turrets is about 2.55mm-2.60mm (0.1 in - 0.102 in), but both of the swagers that would be best suited for this purpose are meant for .062 (1.57mm) to .098 (2.49mm) and for .110 (2.80mm) to .125 (3.20mm)) - the diameter of the RS turrets falls right in the middle. On the other hand, we're talking about a diameter that is just 0.06-0.11mm bigger than the range of the small swager and 0.20mm smaller than the range of the bigger swager. Would this be a problem with either swager - and which one to get for the split top turrets?
I couldn't find anything from RS for this purpose. Harwin offers some tools, but no idea how they look and they are extremely expensive + have to be ordered from manufacturer.
I would appreciate any input on this - has anybody used the Keystone staking tools for the metro split top turrets? How did it work out? I know these can be bought at Mouser and i saw them also on turretboards.com - only question is if they are a perfect fit for this type of turret?
Thank you very much in advance!
Best regards,
VintageCharlie